Is it better to buy new construction or resale in the Alliance area (Harvest, Northlake, Haslet)?
Kallie Spencer's expert breakdown
Whether you choose a brand-new home or a resale in the Alliance area of North Fort Worth, understanding the trade-offs is key — and as a local expert I'll help you decide which path fits your goals and budget.
Why this question matters
When you decide to buy a home — you're making one of the biggest investments of your life. In the Alliance area (including communities like Harvest, Northlake and Haslet, within the 76244/76177 zip code corridors) your decision to buy new construction versus resale will impact cost, timeline, upgrades, resale value, and even your day-to-day life. With my experience as Broker/Owner at Ritchey Realty and deep knowledge of this market, I'll break down pros and cons so you're equipped to make the right choice.
A snapshot of the Alliance area market
The Alliance-North Fort Worth area is growing rapidly, with master-planned communities and new-home subdivisions expanding in places like Northlake and Haslet.
- New-construction homes in DFW generally carry a premium of about 5-10% higher than comparable resale homes.
- Resale homes may come with more immediate availability, mature landscaping and established communities.
- New homes in the far-north corridor offer lots, amenities, and builders' incentives (e.g., lighting, upgrades, rate buydowns) in areas like Northlake.
This means in the Alliance area you'll likely face the same core questions: Are you paying extra for "new"? Are you comfortable with a resale's condition or potential updates? How soon do you need to move in? What matters most: location, lot-size, finishes or cost?
💰 Understanding Builder Incentives: A Key Decision Factor
Builder incentives can be a game-changer for buyers who need help with financing or closing costs. In today's market, many builders in the Alliance area offer substantial incentives that can significantly reduce your out-of-pocket expenses and monthly payments.
Common Builder Incentives Include:
- Rate Buydowns: Builders may offer to buy down your interest rate (e.g., from 6.5% to 5.5%) for the first 1-3 years of your mortgage. This can save you hundreds of dollars per month during the initial years of homeownership.
- Closing Cost Assistance: Many builders contribute $5,000-$15,000+ toward your closing costs, which typically range from 2-5% of your purchase price. This can significantly reduce the cash you need to bring to closing.
- Free Upgrades: Granite countertops, upgraded flooring, smart home packages, or landscaping credits are commonly offered as incentives to sweeten the deal.
- Preferred Lender Incentives: Using the builder's preferred lender often unlocks additional incentives or more favorable terms that aren't available with outside lenders.
Why This Matters for Your Decision:
If you're working with a limited down payment or want to preserve your cash for furniture, moving costs, or reserves, builder incentives can make new construction more accessible than you might think. While new homes typically cost 5-10% more than resale, the incentives can effectively reduce or eliminate that premium.
Important: Builder incentives change frequently based on inventory levels, market conditions, and the builder's need to move homes. As your agent, I stay current on which builders in Harvest, Northlake, and Haslet are offering the best incentive packages, and I'll negotiate to ensure you're getting maximum value.
💡 Pro Tip: Resale homes don't typically offer these types of incentives, though sellers may contribute to closing costs during negotiations. The structured incentive packages from builders can provide more predictable financial benefits.
Pros & Cons: New Construction in the Alliance area
- Everything is brand-new: fresh build, new systems, no prior wear-and-tear. That means less immediate maintenance.
- You'll often get modern-layout features, energy efficiency, builder warranties. In Northlake the "Pecan Square" community touts new homes with smart home features and amenities.
- In some new build communities you'll find incentives: upgrade credits, design centre options, rate/buydown deals. (In DFW the premium may be offset by incentives.)
- If you value having the "first owner", customizing some finishes, and picking your own lot (in builder phases), new works well.
- Higher premium: As noted, new homes in DFW often cost 5-10% more than comparable resale.
- Slower move-in timeline: If the home is under construction, you may wait several months.
- Less established neighbourhoods: Some amenities, landscaping, mature trees or full community build-out may be forthcoming rather than present day.
- Lot-size or location trade-offs: Builders may use peripheral lots, or neighbourhood may be farther from major services or transit.
- HOA and future build-out risk: New communities may have more phases, more future construction nearby, which can impact noise, traffic or views.
Pros & Cons: Resale Homes in the Alliance area
- Generally lower upfront price (for similar house size) because it avoids "builder premium".
- Mature neighbourhoods: trees, established landscaping, maybe shorter completion of community amenities.
- Potential for immediate move-in.
- Possibly better lots (in some older sections) or unique features not found in new build cookie-cut homes.
- You might face more maintenance or need to budget for upgrades: older systems, roof, HVAC.
- Fewer modern layout features or finishes (unless previously renovated).
- Potentially less energy-efficient or design features behind new-construction homes.
- You may find fewer of the open-lot/new-community amenities that many buyers in Alliance seek.
Key Decision Factors You Should Weigh
1. Budget and premium comfort
If you have flexibility and want the latest finishes, new construction helps. But if you're cost-sensitive, resale may give more home for your budget. Because Alliance area incomes are higher (median household income ~$119k) the premium may feel more comfortable for some buyers.
2. Timeline and move-in speed
Need to move quickly? A well-priced resale may serve better. If you're willing to wait for construction and customization, new works.
3. Lot, neighborhood and location
Established resale neighbourhood may offer mature landscaping, fully built amenities, and proven schools. New construction may offer brand-new amenities and modern layouts but check how built-out the community is. In areas like Harvest, Northlake and Haslet there's a mix.
4. Lifestyle & amenities
If you want cutting-edge finishes, modern smart-home features, builder-warranty, new construction wins. If you care more about lot size, mature trees, neighbourhood character, resale may win.
5. Long-term resale value
While both may appreciate, location matters. If your new build is in a slower-to-develop section of a community (or far from amenities) it may not appreciate as quickly as a resale in a fully built, desirable pocket. I'll help you evaluate comps specific to Harvest, Northlake or Haslet to guide that.
6. Inspection and risk
New homes still require inspection (builder-punch list, warranty exclusions). Resales require full inspection (roof age, foundation/soil issues, drainage-flood risk) especially in North Fort Worth's soil conditions.
My Recommendation for the Alliance Area
As your local expert, here's my "bottom line" advice based on your situation:
- If you prioritize move-in ready, modern finishes, low maintenance, and can accommodate a slightly higher price — go new construction in a well-amenitized community like Harvest or Northlake.
- If you want to maximise value, prefer a bit more negotiation room, want to move sooner, or favour a mature neighbourhood feel — a resale home in Haslet or an established part of the Alliance area may be a smarter fit.
Regardless of path, always work with a knowledgeable agent (that's me) who knows the nuances: builder incentives, resale comparables, lot positioning, community build-out plans, and future traffic/development around AllianceTexas.
What I'll Do for You as Your Agent
As Broker/Owner at Ritchey Realty, here's how I support you:
- I'll pull recent sales data for both new-construction and resale homes in Harvest, Northlake and Haslet (last 6-12 months) so you can compare true cost per square foot, appreciation, lot size and finishes.
- I'll schedule showings in both categories so you can feel the difference firsthand.
- I'll evaluate builder incentives, upgrade costs, HOA/amenity fees and compare to resale home risk/upgrade costs.
- I'll negotiate on your behalf — whether it's builder contract terms or a resale home inspection contingency.
- I'll help you understand "what you're really paying for" — not just the sticker price but long-term cost, maintenance, resale potential.
Buyer Checklist – New vs Resale
| Item | For New Construction | For Resale |
|---|---|---|
| Price premium | Expect +5-10% above resale comps. | Better chance to negotiate below new-build level. |
| Move-in timeline | May wait months until completion. | Usually quicker move-in if already built. |
| Lot/neighbourhood maturity | Amenities may still be under development. | Trees, full amenities, community history present. |
| Upgrade & finish control | Choose your finishes; may incur upgrade costs. | Existing finishes; some may need updates. |
| Maintenance/risk | Fewer near-term repairs; builder warranty. | Possible repair/upgrade costs sooner. |
| Resale value risk | New home in undeveloped section may have more risk. | Established resale in matured community may hold value better. |
Final Thoughts
Choosing between a new construction home and a resale home in the Alliance area of North Fort Worth truly comes down to your priorities: budget, timeline, lifestyle, and willingness to trade-off features versus cost.
I'm Kallie Spencer, Broker/Owner at Ritchey Realty — working specifically in Harvest, Northlake and Haslet. I'd be happy to walk you through both sides of the equation, show you live listings in each category, and craft a strategy that aligns with you.
If you're ready to explore options, compare new build vs resale side by side, and decide what's best in the Alliance area — contact me today.
📞 Contact Kallie Spencer
Connect on Social Media:
Specializing in Alliance Area, Harvest, Northlake, Haslet & North Fort Worth Real Estate
